From: Robert Benschop (rbenschop_at_euronet.nl)
Date: Tue Feb 17 2004 - 07:38:25 PST
On 17-feb-04, at 15:57, Sushi wrote:
> When CDs were introduced, the so called audiophiles reacted the same
> way.
> The sound quality with CDs was not as good. You could actually hear
> the
> difference they claimed. Some went so far as to state that music was
> being butchered via conversion to CD. Yet today, everyone seems to
> support the CD as the music standard for quality sound.
Not to rehash an old OT discussion about this (there's plenty in the
archives) just a few facts:
I play CD's on a high-end configuration but the difference with vinyl
can be done blindfolded (and I don't mean the pops etc.)
Same for original CDs vs. copied
Same for copied vs. mp3
Even copied on different brands of CDs and different burning speeds
could be picked out.
Read this well, all tests done blind. I am not a believer by nature ;-)
> ...and I have yet to hear someone state that they miss the infamous
> "pops" made when playing a regular vinyl record.
We could hold a meeting bigger than all the Newton users in the world
combined...
> Anyhow, I would venture to say, that the average person can not tell
> the
> difference between a CD version and a quality MP3 recording of a song
> when played through the same system.
Absolutely true.
> And to have the advantage of carrying around a huge collection in the
> palm of your hand, in itself, is reason enough to have an iPod or mini
> iPod.
Again true.
> As for me, I am not looking back...there is no reason to. The popular
> DL'ing of digital music is here to stay it looks like.
I'm looking both ways. Will probably buy an MP3 solution for in the
car, but it won't enter my living room...
But your point is valid, most stereo's won't let you hear the
difference anyway and most young ears have been ravished by loud car
stereos etc. by now.
Robert Benschop
-- This is the NewtonTalk list - http://www.newtontalk.net/ for all inquiries List FAQ/Etiquette/Terms: http://www.newtontalk.net/faq.html Official Newton FAQ: http://www.chuma.org/newton/faq/
This archive was generated by hypermail 2.1.5 : Tue Feb 17 2004 - 08:00:01 PST